Forestry managers have no power to stop damaging logging: watchdog

The Forest Practices Board says district managers need the authority to withhold cutting permits if they pose hazards
District forest managers can't withhold cutting permits even when concerns about a company's logging plans are raised.

On a routine basis, district forest managers raise red flags over forestry practices that pose potential public safety hazards, threaten wildlife and community watersheds, and could trigger landslides, but have no authority to stop it.

That’s the conclusion of a special report just released by the Forest Practices Board.

The report, which has been submitted to Forests Minister Steve Thomson, cites numerous examples where district managers were forced to issue permits to timber licence holders, despite knowing that doing so could pose risks and potential violations.

Some of the incidents and risks cited include:

• the cutting of non-pine species in areas where only pine infested with Mountain pine beetle was supposed to be harvested;

• a pine beetle salvage harvesting operation that left downstream water users at risk of runoff from mine tailings;

• a complaint about upstream logging where a lack of coordination between various forest license holders “increased the likelihood of flooding” of a ranch downstream;

• plans to log on steep slopes with a history of landslides at Laird Creek that raised concerns by residents that the district manager had no authority to address;

• the inability of the district manager to protect a newly discovered northern goshawk nest from logging on Haida Gwaii.

“In recent years, the Forest Practices Board has seen situations arise where forestry development was putting local environmental and community values at risk, yet district managers could do little to affect the development and protect the public interest,” the report states.

District managers used to have some discretion to ensure that forestry companies with harvesting licences were conducting forestry and road building operations that met government expectations.

But they lost that authority in 2004 when the B.C. government scrapped the Forest Practices Code – considered overly bureaucratic – for the Forest and Ranges Practices Act.

District managers are the ministry’s eyes and ears on the ground. They issue cutting permits, but as long as the permits meet three main objectives, they have no choice but to issue them, even when they have concerns about the licence holder’s plans, or when concerns are brought to their attention by the public.

“He has no legal ability to question or ensure what’s been proposed with respect to visual quality objectives or road construction or something else has actually been done,” Forest Practices Board chairman Tim Ryan told Business in Vancouver.

An incident on Haida Gwaii in 2013 is one example. The Council of the Haida Nation raised concerns over the harvesting plans of Teal Cedar Products Ltd. The main concern was over the visual impact of the company’s logging plans.

During a field review, forestry officials identified potential problems with the company’s plans with respect to the visual impact the logging would have. But when the district manager asked the company for its visual impact assessment, the company refused to provide them.

The district manager had no authority to withhold the company’s cutting permit, and the result was an eyesore.

“The visual quality plan that was designed did not end up being produced on the ground,” Ryan said.

Ryan said the concerns raised in the recent special report have been raised before in previous reports.

He said the board wants district managers to be granted the discretion to delay or withhold a permit from being issued, should a licensee's logging plans or activities fail to comply with the overarching objectives of the government Forest Stewardship Plan.

comments powered by Disqus

More from Forestry & Fisheries

B.C. forestry giants post strong earnings, despite duties

B.C. Premier John Horgan optimistic a softwood deal can be reached following U.S. visit

Read Article

BIV on Global BC August 8, 2017: Softwood lumber battle; American Apparel ...

Hayley Woodin discusses the softwood lumber battle. Plus: American Apparel is set for a big comeback.

Read Article

Commercial fishing sector braces for another bad year

B.C. fishermen facing limited or no openings for sockeye

Read Article

Fluctuating forest industry performs well in first quarter

Accounting firm PwC reports positive findings despite looming forestry concerns

Read Article

Forest industry could lead way in meeting B.C. climate goals: study

Read Article

Subscribe to our mailing lists

You may withdraw your consent at any time.

* indicates required


* You can modify your newsletter subscriptions at the bottom of any newsletter you receive.
Business in Vancouver Media Group
303 West 5th Avenue, Vancouver, British Columbia
V5Y 1J6 · Canada